Reviews:

The Brutal Politics of Benny Andrews at Michael Rosenfeld, New York

Benny Andrews, Circle, 1973; oil on 12 linen canvases with painted fabric and mixed media collage, 120 by 288 inches.
Benny Andrews, Circle, 1973; oil on 12 linen canvases with painted fabric and mixed media collage, 120 by 288 inches. © Estate of Benny Andrews/Licensed by VAGA, New York, NY. and Michael Rosenfeld Gallery, New York, NY.

A little over four decades ago, Georgia-born painter Benny Andrews (1930-2006) completed his six-part masterwork, The Bicentennial Series. It was 1975, and cultural institutions across the country were busy organizing special exhibitions and programs to mark the two-hundredth anniversary of America’s independence. The 1976 bicentennial celebration was shaping up to be a sentimental commemoration of patriotism and national pride. Andrews, a Black artist from the rural South living in New York City at the time, felt compelled to bring a different narrative to fruition. Benny Andrews: The Bicentennial Series, on view at Michael Rosenfeld Gallery in New York, couldn’t be more relevant today—it’s a blazing meditation on the torments of war, the fate of our planet, and the monstrousness of sexism and racism in America.

The exhibition wastes no time in introducing visitors to the brute force of Andrews’s surrealist imagery. Sexism is the first group of paintings and drawings that viewers encounter in the gallery, and it contains some of the most disturbing images in the series. White-skinned masculine beings with clawed feet and rodent faces wear patriotic red, white, and blue mantles over their otherwise naked bodies. Phallic symbols abound in the form of lollipop-shaped trees and arrow quivers or missiles between the legs of the male creatures.

Benny Andrews, Sexism Study #22, 1973; oil on five stretched canvas panels, 30 by 90 inches.
Benny Andrews, Sexism Study #22, 1973; oil on five stretched canvas panels, 30 by 90 inches. (All images courtesy the Estate of Benny Andrews/Licensed by VAGA, New York, NY. and Michael Rosenfeld Gallery, New York, NY.)

Sexism Study #24 shows a female form in fighting stance, legs spread and white-gloved fists raised, but the figure’s movement seems to be thwarted by a covering over her head and body, and ropes attached to domestic objects that anchor her to the ground. This composition is repeated in Sexism Study #15, in which a covered male figure is tethered by ropes connected to metal plates. The cloth over his head and body is red, white, and blue, and decorated with stars and stripes. Andrews peels back the layers around gender roles in American culture, and what he reveals is absurd and creepy. The female figures in Sexism are mostly depicted as trapped and victimized, but the cretinous males, surrounded by images of sex and power, can also be interpreted as victims.

The F Word at Hunter Museum

Andrews completed over seventy paintings and drawings for Sexism alone, and at least 200 works for the five other themes in his series. Only fifty-seven pieces from Bicentennial are included in the show despite the gallery’s spaciousness. The monumental scale of Andrews’s undertaking speaks to his level of outrage. Sexism is rife with representations of sexual oppression. In Symbols, he delved into his own roots as one of ten children born to sharecroppers in Plainview, Georgia, and depicted provincial scenes of a poor Black community overshadowed by hardship and haunted by symbols of American injustice.

Andrews’s art and his political activism were always entwined, but when he chose Trash as his second theme in the series, the connections between his art and activism became more urgent. He was working on Trash in 1971 when 1,000 prisoners at Attica Correctional Facility in upstate New York rioted and took over the prison for four days. The inmates released a list of demands for better living conditions and civil rights, and Andrews was deeply moved by their plight.

"Benny
Benny Andrews, Liberty (Study #2 for Trash), 1971; oil on linen, 34 by 22 inches.

The Attica incident gave Andrews the inspiration for what became his “symbol of [Blackness]” in Trash. He had already established images of American nationalism and culture as his “symbols of [whiteness]” (a quote from the 1972 ACA Gallery Trash exhibition catalogue, according to Rosenfeld Gallery notes). His painting style in Trash is distinctly expressionistic compared to the more precise depictions in Sexism. Sexism is surreal fantasy; Trash feels real. In Puller (Study #1 for Trash), the figure’s thrown-back head, straining arms, and elongated feet are loosely painted, enhancing the sense of tension and struggle in the image. In Liberty (Study #2 for Trash), the people depicted are almost devoid of detail. A globe is supported on the shoulders of three simply drawn white figures. The United States is front and center on the globe; a featureless Statue of Liberty sits casually on top. In sharp relief against the red, white, and blue palette is a figure painted in solid black who is attached to the globe as if crucified or lynched. Even in its simplicity, the black form radiates energy, the sole figure in the painting who seems real and alive, a palpable representation of suffering and entrapment beneath America’s fetishistic symbol of freedom.

The full force of Andrews’s political convictions finds expression in War, where he uses his signature collage technique to devastating effect. In War (Study #1) bits of fabric and rope amplify the otherwise flat canvas. The soldier’s shirt is rendered in pieces of painted cloth; rope circles the ankles of a man slung over his shoulder. But it’s through the complex dimensionality of the soldier’s face that Andrews hurls his message at the viewer. The man’s eyes are empty holes cut in an oval of painted canvas. The distended nose appears to have been ripped off and then re-attached with thick paint. A molded piece of canvas is attached to part of the mouth, the protruding lip painted in fleshy high gloss. It is the face of war, represented by a death mask, both expressionless and anguished.

Benny Andrews, War Study #1
Benny Andrews, War (Study #1), 1974; oil and graphite on canvas with painted fabric collage, 34 by 25 by 1¼ inches.

Andrews was a veteran of the Korean War and an energetic opponent of the Vietnam War, which was still raging when he was working on War in 1974. He approached the subject the way he approached every theme in The Bicentennial Series, by harnessing the raw symbolism that was at the core of the experience. This is especially true in Circle, the only monumental painting in the exhibition. It looks like an altarpiece. The central figure appears to be a Black man bound in the pose of a crucifixion to a bare, stained mattress. His heart, represented by a watermelon, has been removed and is held aloft by ropes. A circle of white figures grasp the ropes; two Black women sit observing. Andrews is calling on all his powers of dreamlike expression and surreal symbolism in this depiction of a tormented Black man experiencing the ritualistic extraction of his essence.

SCAD - Derrick Adams

In 1975 came Utopia, the sixth and final installment of The Bicentennial Series, in which Andrews expressed his ideas of an idyllic world. The oil and collage painting Utopias Study #8 is significantly devoid of human life. Five drawings in the exhibition depict people in fetal poses lying inside oval, egg-shaped holes. In Utopias Study 5-C, two embryonic beings converse as they lounge comfortably on the ground. Andrews’s idea of utopia seems to suggest that ideally, it should be absent of human life, and if man exists at all, he is best left in a perpetually nascent state.

Andrews was a prolific journal writer; his papers, including family correspondence and other writings, were donated to the Stuart A. Rose Manuscript, Archives, and Rare Book Library at Emory University upon his death from cancer in 2006. Quotes from his journals and excerpts from interviews and exhibition catalogues appear in the highly informative texts that accompany Benny Andrews: The Bicentennial Series exhibition. One particular line from Andrews in a 1977 Houston Chronicle article provides meaningful context for understanding his work. Andrews said, “Surrealism can get out of hand real fast. But then the [Black] experience is so ridiculous that surrealism is the best way to express it. I’ve seen the same kind of work coming from prison artists. To get through an oppressive real life, the artists have to live a fantasy life.” You can’t help but wonder what symbols Andrews would invoke to represent today’s America.


Benny Andrews: The Bicentennial Series was on view at Michael Rosenfeld Gallery through January 21, 2017.